Three Tab vs. Architectural Shingles
Three Tab vs. Architectural Shingles
Composition asphalt shingles come in two basic varieties: Three tab shingles and architectural shingles (also called dimensional shingles). So which one is better? The answer is “it depends.” There are advantages and disadvantages of each type and the right one for each homeowner depends on that homeowner’s situation.
Three tab shingles have been the industry standard for decades. They can be found on millions of homes throughout the United States and although they are slowly losing market share to architectural shingles and other roofing materials such as metal roofing, they are still the most commonly used residential roofing material today.
Three tab shingles can be easily identified by their uniform rectangular tabs and the flat appearance of the roof. Three tab shingles have historically gotten a bad rap due to poor shingle quality and shoddy installation techniques. These days, the quality of three tab shingles has greatly improved and most reputable local roofing contractors understand and follow best industry practices, resulting in a good quality roof at an affordable price.
Architectural shingles are thicker and heavier than three tab shingles and are manufactured to provide a non-uniform, textured look to the roof that resembles cedar shakes. They were initially marketed for high end homes and continue to be of generally higher quality than all but the best three tab shingles. Architectural shingles also have higher wind and impact resistance ratings and carry warranties of at least 25 years. Some manufacturers offer lifetime warranties on their architectural shingles.
As you might expect, architectural shingles are more expensive than three tab shingles. Expect to pay about 30% more for high quality architectural shingles than you would for good three tab shingles.
